Bias in The Media Article Analysis




PURPOSE: To criticize Trump's approach to student loans
DEVICES:

Pathos: The article uses fear to back up its argument. Statements like “his stance on student loans could spell trouble for liberal arts majors” at the beginning of the article start the reader off with a negative or fearful feeling about the topic despite no evidence having been presented at that point in the article. This creates a lens through which the reader sees the article and influences their opinions. This combined with the headline “This is Trump's stance on student loans - and it could hurt poor students” makes it seem to the reader like someone or even themselves is in imminent danger and needs to oppose the idea being explored by the article. This happens before any evidence or description of the problem is presented that can either bring substance to this fear or prove that it is baseless forcing the reader to be against the idea from the start.

Pronouns: This article focuses on Donald Trump's proposed policies before he was elected. The policies have not yet been carried out at the time of this articles writing but the article makes a point to contrast them with not only Hillary contains proposed policies but also Obama's policies and ideas. This groups the reader together with both Obama and Clinton as us vs them (the untested policies of Donald Trump and his supporters). This forces the reader to side with one or the other without defining what that means.

Argument Structure: the article first presents a policy advisor for Trump's campaign explaining the basic outline of his policy on student loans. After this, the article continued with an interview from the president of Washington college addressing those policies. The interview picks apart the proposed policy and talks about how it would disadvantage various areas of study especially for low-income students and change the way colleges look at admissions, favoring certain professions. The article ends after that, excluding any counterpoints that the policy advisor could have made as well as leaving the reader on a negative note regarding the topic and the policy.


BIAS:

Bias Through Omission: The article omits any positive outcome of the new policy. It only talks about its negative impact on a very specific type of student and area of study, how it “could spell trouble” for liberal arts students with debt. The subtext of the article is also biased. It mentions the plans of other presidential candidates which are free college policies and portrays them as “rejected” by Trump while being the superior alternative to Trump's policy. The article, however, does not mention the high cost or any of the negatives associated with free public college.

Bias Through Word Choice: The article uses consistently negative words or connotation when describing Trump's policy. It would be “expensive” and “troublesome” or “risky” while the alternative policy allows for “good jobs” and support for any career. This assigns a negative connotation to anything that relates to trump while painting his opposition in a positive light even without evidence for those feelings. The reader comes away with trump being negative and his opposition or alternative being good even without the context of the specific topic being discussed.









Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Image
Gender In Advertising  1. The advertisements have different images and are laid out slightly different from one another, the picture switches sides from the left on the boy's ad to the right on the girl's ad. The position and expression of the children in the ad change from a more active or dynamic expression for the boy to a calm expression for the girl. The text and advertising points are also different and appeal to how the child is expected to behave. 2. I personally never had an opinion about the GAP but this ad comparison shows the different expectations the company has for boys and girls. The company is trying to appeal to what it believes are the character traits of the 2 genders at this age regardless of their accuracy. 3. I think that the portrayal of boys and girls is very stereotypical for kids that age. Girls are expected to become social butterflies and be outgoing and friendly while boys are expected to be smart and active with lots of energy a...
Read more
Image
Today I was asked  in class to analyze advertising and compare two advertisements. I chose to do  print car advertisements. The first advertisement I chose to analyze was an ad for an affordable minivan. The ad is for an everyday car and follows a theme of comparison. The ad for the minivan is simple and has one image of the car on a background of white text. This keeps the focus on the image and does not clutter up or confuse the eyes. At the top of the add there is a large bold statement meant to compare the car to a much more expensive car. The advertisement is aimed at new car buyers. The car company in question is Daihatsu, a Japanese company famous for making small cars. The perspective of the advertisement seems to be that of someone who is interested in cars for their cool factor or how they are perceived in society. This is because of the ad’s statement, “Picks up five times more women than a Lamborghini”. This statement also show that the te target au...
Read more
Image
I think that like most people, doing what I like makes me happiest. Working on projects or building something that interests me without the stress of deadlines or work I don't want to do. I think that a national happiness index would be an interesting thing to try.the results however I don't think should affect national policy because people's definitions of happiness can be very different. Some people's happiness could even be the exact opposite of happiness for others. This could lead to conflict in terms of actual policy but it still would be an interesting study to do. I think that because of this there is also no one way to measure happiness. Happiness is relative to what makes you unhappy. Some persons definition of perfection could still be below the definition of someone else's unhappiness. Kurt Vonnegut's article, I've Been Called A Luddite, talks about how he remembers  time before technology was involved in all that we do. He talks about the...
Read more